Tibial plateau angle measuremet in dogs – comparison of three different methods
Аутори
Todorović, Anastasija Z.Krstić, Nikola E.
Žikić, Dragan R.
Van Bree, Henri JJ.
Mlv. Gielen, Ingrid
Lazarević Macanović, Mirjana
Чланак у часопису (Објављена верзија)
Метаподаци
Приказ свих података о документуАпстракт
The aim of this study was to establish two new methods for measuring the tibial plateau
angle (TPA): proximal tibial circle (PTC) as well as full tibial circle (FTC) method, and
to test their reliability in comparison to the classical method (CM). Three radiologists
implemented each method, and measurements were repeated three times.
The results of consecutive measurements obtained by two observers had excellent
reliability with an interclass correlation coefficient (ICC) greater than 0.9 for all
methods, while measurements obtained by the third observer had good reliability for
the CM (ICC=0.885) and PTC method (ICC=0.851).
The results obtained by the three observers for all methods indicate good reliability for
the PTC and FTC methods (ICC=0.848 and 0.880, respectively) and excellent reliability
for CM (ICC = 0.909); the results of the different observers for each method were not
significantly different.
The significant difference resulting from the applied measurement me...thod (ICC =
0.447 and P<0.01) was confirmed. Statistically significant differences were not found
between the CM and PTC method (P>0.05), while differences between the PTC and
FTC, as well as CM and FTC methods, were statistically significant (P<0.01).
New methods for TPA measurements based on shorter tibial axes may be an alternative
to a method based on the full-length axis. A high correlation between the methods
indicates the precision of each of them. Newly established methods can be used when
the tarsal joint is not included in radiographs or is affected by degenerative changes,
making use of the classical method not possible.
Кључне речи:
dog / cranial cruciate ligament / stifle joint / tibial axis / tibial plateau angle / tibial plateau slopeИзвор:
Acta Veterinaria, 2024, 74, 1, 17-29Издавач:
- Beograd : Fakultet veterinarske medicine
Финансирање / пројекти:
- Министарство науке, технолошког развоја и иновација Републике Србије, институционално финансирање - 200143 (Универзитет у Београду, Факултет ветеринарске медицине) (RS-MESTD-inst-2020-200143)
Колекције
Институција/група
Fakultet veterinarske medicineTY - JOUR AU - Todorović, Anastasija Z. AU - Krstić, Nikola E. AU - Žikić, Dragan R. AU - Van Bree, Henri JJ. AU - Mlv. Gielen, Ingrid AU - Lazarević Macanović, Mirjana PY - 2024 UR - https://vet-erinar.vet.bg.ac.rs/handle/123456789/3761 AB - The aim of this study was to establish two new methods for measuring the tibial plateau angle (TPA): proximal tibial circle (PTC) as well as full tibial circle (FTC) method, and to test their reliability in comparison to the classical method (CM). Three radiologists implemented each method, and measurements were repeated three times. The results of consecutive measurements obtained by two observers had excellent reliability with an interclass correlation coefficient (ICC) greater than 0.9 for all methods, while measurements obtained by the third observer had good reliability for the CM (ICC=0.885) and PTC method (ICC=0.851). The results obtained by the three observers for all methods indicate good reliability for the PTC and FTC methods (ICC=0.848 and 0.880, respectively) and excellent reliability for CM (ICC = 0.909); the results of the different observers for each method were not significantly different. The significant difference resulting from the applied measurement method (ICC = 0.447 and P<0.01) was confirmed. Statistically significant differences were not found between the CM and PTC method (P>0.05), while differences between the PTC and FTC, as well as CM and FTC methods, were statistically significant (P<0.01). New methods for TPA measurements based on shorter tibial axes may be an alternative to a method based on the full-length axis. A high correlation between the methods indicates the precision of each of them. Newly established methods can be used when the tarsal joint is not included in radiographs or is affected by degenerative changes, making use of the classical method not possible. PB - Beograd : Fakultet veterinarske medicine T2 - Acta Veterinaria T1 - Tibial plateau angle measuremet in dogs – comparison of three different methods VL - 74 IS - 1 SP - 17 EP - 29 DO - 10.2478/acve-2024-0002 ER -
@article{ author = "Todorović, Anastasija Z. and Krstić, Nikola E. and Žikić, Dragan R. and Van Bree, Henri JJ. and Mlv. Gielen, Ingrid and Lazarević Macanović, Mirjana", year = "2024", abstract = "The aim of this study was to establish two new methods for measuring the tibial plateau angle (TPA): proximal tibial circle (PTC) as well as full tibial circle (FTC) method, and to test their reliability in comparison to the classical method (CM). Three radiologists implemented each method, and measurements were repeated three times. The results of consecutive measurements obtained by two observers had excellent reliability with an interclass correlation coefficient (ICC) greater than 0.9 for all methods, while measurements obtained by the third observer had good reliability for the CM (ICC=0.885) and PTC method (ICC=0.851). The results obtained by the three observers for all methods indicate good reliability for the PTC and FTC methods (ICC=0.848 and 0.880, respectively) and excellent reliability for CM (ICC = 0.909); the results of the different observers for each method were not significantly different. The significant difference resulting from the applied measurement method (ICC = 0.447 and P<0.01) was confirmed. Statistically significant differences were not found between the CM and PTC method (P>0.05), while differences between the PTC and FTC, as well as CM and FTC methods, were statistically significant (P<0.01). New methods for TPA measurements based on shorter tibial axes may be an alternative to a method based on the full-length axis. A high correlation between the methods indicates the precision of each of them. Newly established methods can be used when the tarsal joint is not included in radiographs or is affected by degenerative changes, making use of the classical method not possible.", publisher = "Beograd : Fakultet veterinarske medicine", journal = "Acta Veterinaria", title = "Tibial plateau angle measuremet in dogs – comparison of three different methods", volume = "74", number = "1", pages = "17-29", doi = "10.2478/acve-2024-0002" }
Todorović, A. Z., Krstić, N. E., Žikić, D. R., Van Bree, H. JJ., Mlv. Gielen, I.,& Lazarević Macanović, M.. (2024). Tibial plateau angle measuremet in dogs – comparison of three different methods. in Acta Veterinaria Beograd : Fakultet veterinarske medicine., 74(1), 17-29. https://doi.org/10.2478/acve-2024-0002
Todorović AZ, Krstić NE, Žikić DR, Van Bree HJ, Mlv. Gielen I, Lazarević Macanović M. Tibial plateau angle measuremet in dogs – comparison of three different methods. in Acta Veterinaria. 2024;74(1):17-29. doi:10.2478/acve-2024-0002 .
Todorović, Anastasija Z., Krstić, Nikola E., Žikić, Dragan R., Van Bree, Henri JJ., Mlv. Gielen, Ingrid, Lazarević Macanović, Mirjana, "Tibial plateau angle measuremet in dogs – comparison of three different methods" in Acta Veterinaria, 74, no. 1 (2024):17-29, https://doi.org/10.2478/acve-2024-0002 . .